Found the caddy was a little tight to fit into my bottle cages, (where bottles fit no problem) and because of that the top kept popping off, which getting worse over time ultimately meant I had to ditch it.

for the money it's OK value, but will just stick to a tool roll now

It's the right size for the job, but would benefit from a bit of foam padding in the lid. Scratches very easily, a few times in out the holder and it looks pretty rough.